Skip to Main Content
It looks like you're using Internet Explorer 11 or older. This website works best with modern browsers such as the latest versions of Chrome, Firefox, Safari, and Edge. If you continue with this browser, you may see unexpected results.

Resources for Research Assistants

Substance checking, example 2: work lacks citation to a law review article

Scenario: the following sentence appears in the article that you are checking, with no accompanying citation: Rakove suggests that Hylton v. U.S. would be a more significant case to discuss with regard to the origins of judicial review than Marbury v. Madison.

  1. Need for a citation: the sentence clearly needs a citation, so consider how to locate the source of this information. Do surrounding footnotes provide a clue about the Rakove article being referenced here? If not…
  2. Figure out the source: use clues. Here, at least the author’s name and some good keywords have been provided, which should help if the source is available electronically. There are a few tactics to employ:
    1. Run some searches in online databases that would likely contain the source. Here, it is a good bet that this is from a law review article, so search a full-text database such as the law review & journals databases on Westlaw, Lexis, or HeinOnline using the author field (Rakove) and the text field (Marbury & Hylton). This method leads to Rakove’s article The Origins of Judicial Review: A Plea for New Contexts, 49 Stan. L. Rev. 1031, 1039-41.
    2. Search the library catalog for the author’s name and the keywords (perhaps, judicial review). Be sure to click on the Articles tab if searching for a law review or other type of article.
    3. Search Google for the author’s name and subject matter; this could lead to the article or book being cited.
    4. Again, if these basic tactics do not lead to a credible source, check with the author (or, as appropriate, the journal editor).
  3. Confirm the substance: the statement above accurately summarizes the point that Rakove makes on pages 1039-41 of his article. If the author’s sentence resembles a quotation (i.e., if the language is very close to the language used in the source), turn it back into a quotation, and flag it for the author.